This post is for information only. You are responsible for reviewing and using this information appropriately. This content doesn’t contain and isn’t meant to provide legal, tax, or business advice. Requirements are updated frequently, and you should make sure to do your own research and reach out to professional legal, tax, and business advisers, as needed. To sell products using the Shopify platform, you must comply with the laws of the jurisdiction of your business and your customers, the Shopify Terms of Service, the Shopify Acceptable Use Policy, and any other applicable policies.
Fraud prevention in your store means using tools and policies to identify and stop fraudulent activity before you lose money.
In the US, every dollar lost to fraud costs retail and ecommerce businesses around $5.13 in total, according to the 2026 LexisNexis True Cost of Fraud study.
Ahead, learn how to spot common types of fraud, choose prevention measures, and compare Shopify’s fraud tools.
What is fraud prevention?
Fraud prevention is the set of controls a business uses to detect and stop unauthorized or fraudulent transactions. These controls include payment verification and manual order reviews. For example, a store can hold a suspicious order for investigation before shipping it.
A solid ecommerce fraud prevention strategy covers fraud detection, customer authentication, order review, and controls against policy abuse, with regular updates as threats evolve. Dispute handling is part of the broader work of managing fraud after a transaction.
Shopify’s fraud solutions support prevention, detection, and management:
- Fraud prevention helps block fraudulent payments. 3D Secure authentication helps verify the buyer’s identity, while integrated card testing protection helps stop attempts to test stolen card details at checkout.
- Fraud detection helps identify risky orders. Shopify’s fraud analysis uses machine learning trained on historical transactions across Shopify stores.
- Fraud management helps you act on risk and respond to disputes. Shopify Flow can tag orders for review or cancel high-risk orders after fraud analysis is complete. For card payment disputes through Shopify Payments, Shopify automatically includes available order information and helps prepare the chargeback response.
Why is fraud prevention important?
A fraudulent order can cost your store staff time, erode customer trust, and increase legal exposure. Here’s where prevention can make a difference:
Financial losses and instability
A fraudulent order can leave you paying for shipped products after the payment is reversed. Chargeback fees and the work involved in disputing the claim add to the loss.
Friendly fraud occurs when a customer incorrectly disputes a legitimate purchase, either by mistake or on purpose. According to the 2026 Global Ecommerce Payments and Fraud Report, surveyed merchants estimated an average cost of $82 to resolve a single first-party misuse dispute.
Reputation risks
If someone takes over a customer’s account, that customer can lose confidence in your store’s security. Repeated requests for information or unexplained delays during an investigation can further damage their trust. Negative reviews and warnings to friends can then discourage other people from buying your products.
Overly strict fraud controls can also cost you customers. In LexisNexis Risk Solutions’ 2026 True Cost of Fraud Study, 56% of US retailers and 54% of US ecommerce merchants reported increased customer churn linked to anti-fraud measures.
Legal compliance issues
US online retailers generally aren’t subject to federal anti-money laundering (AML) program requirements, which apply to covered businesses such as banks and money services businesses. A retailer of precious metals, stones, or jewels can be covered if it buys more than $50,000 of these goods a year from sources such as the public
But retailers still have legal obligations to protect sensitive customer information. Inadequate security that exposes customer data can lead to regulatory action. Fraud prevention measures that restrict unauthorized account access help reduce that exposure.
Efficiency challenges
Investigating suspicious orders and responding to chargebacks can pull staff away from other activities, like fulfillment and customer service.
A single dispute can involve locating delivery records and reviewing customer correspondence before submitting evidence. Clear review procedures help your team gather the relevant records and respond before dispute deadlines.
Before seafood retailer Maine Lobster Now moved to Shopify, fraud review was close to a full-time job. One team member flagged large orders and called customers to confirm they were real.
After the brand switched to Shop Pay, chargebacks due to fraud fell from 0.25% of total transactions to 0.025%, a 93% reduction. That team member now focuses on customer experience.
“I used to have an agent, and almost her whole job was fraud. Now she doesn’t have to deal with that anymore,” says Founder and CEO Julian Klenda.
Types of fraud
- Phishing scams
- Friendly fraud
- Card testing fraud
- Refund abuse
- Loyalty abuse
- Account takeover fraud
- Triangulation fraud
- Identity theft
- AI-enabled and agentic fraud
Online stores can lose money through stolen payment details or false order claims. One risk is card-not-present (CNP) fraud, which occurs when someone makes an unauthorized purchase remotely with stolen card details. In the Federal Reserve’s survey of large US debit card issuers, merchants absorbed 65.1% of CNP fraud losses in 2023.
Phishing scams
Phishing scams impersonate a trusted person or business to steal sensitive information. For example, a fake email that looks like it comes from your bank might direct you to a login page that captures your password.
North American merchants surveyed for the 2026 Global eCommerce Payments and Fraud Report ranked phishing and related attacks third among the fraud types surveyed, affecting 37% of surveyed merchants.
For Shopify stores, a phishing message might impersonate Shopify Support and ask for login details or two-step authentication codes. Always check the sender’s full email address and contact support through Shopify’s official channels if a message looks suspicious.
Friendly fraud
Friendly fraud, a form of first-party misuse, happens when a customer disputes a charge for one of two reasons: they genuinely don’t recognize it, or they falsely claim they never authorized it. The resulting payment reversal is a chargeback. Chargebacks also protect customers with valid complaints, such as goods that never arrived.
In the 2026 study, 64% of surveyed merchants reported increasing rates of first-party misuse.
Card testing fraud
With card testing fraud, attackers check whether stolen card details work, often through small payment attempts. In enumeration attacks, a related scheme, bots submit repeated payment attempts that cycle through card numbers, expiration dates, and security codes until they find a valid combination.
Shopify Payments has card testing protection to help prevent these attacks at checkout.
Shopify’s fraud analysis lists Address Verification System (AVS) results among the fraud indicators to check on each order. AVS compares the billing address’s numbers and postal code with the card issuer’s records.
A mismatch is one risk signal. Automatic declines for failed AVS postal-code checks apply when you enable that Shopify Payments setting, provided the card-issuing bank supports the check.
Refund abuse
Refund fraud involves obtaining a refund through a false claim or dishonest return. One example is “wardrobing”: buying an outfit, wearing it, then returning it as unworn.
Refund and policy abuse was the most commonly reported fraud type in the 2026 Global eCommerce Payments and Fraud Report, affecting 41% of surveyed businesses.
National Retail Federation (NRF) and Happy Returns’ 2025 research, which surveyed large US retailers, found that 9% of returns were fraudulent. The report projected total US merchandise returns at $849.9 billion that year.
Loyalty abuse
Loyalty abuse is the theft or dishonest collection of customer rewards. A fraudster might break into a customer’s account and redeem their points. The 2026 report found that 24% of surveyed merchants experienced loyalty fraud.
Account takeover fraud
Account takeover fraud occurs when someone gains unauthorized access to an existing account.
With stolen login details, an intruder may be able to use saved payment methods, depending on the account’s payment security controls. They can then place orders through an account that already has a purchase history with your store.
In a Pew Research Center survey published in July 2025, 29% of US adults surveyed said someone had hacked one of their personal online accounts, such as a social media, email, or bank account.
Triangulation fraud
Triangulation fraud involves three parties: a shopper, a scammer, and a store. The scammer lists a product for sale, often on a marketplace, and collects the shopper’s payment. Then the scammer buys that product from a store with stolen card details and has them ship it to the shopper.
The shopper receives the order, and the scammer keeps the payment. When the real cardholder disputes the unauthorized purchase, your store faces a chargeback for goods it has already shipped.
Identity theft
Identity theft is the unauthorized use of someone else’s personal information to commit fraud. A scammer might open a shopping account in the victim’s name and place orders using stolen card details. The order may appear legitimate because the name and billing information match the cardholder’s records.
According to Veriff’s Identity Fraud Report 2026, impersonation accounted for more than 85% of the fraudulent verification attempts it observed in 2025.
AI-enabled and agentic fraud
AI-enabled fraud uses artificial intelligence to create or scale attacks, from personalized phishing messages to purchases with stolen card details. Agentic AI fraud goes further by planning and carrying out multiple steps with limited human input, such as finding and exploiting loopholes in a loyalty program.
In a 2025 Deloitte survey of 39 North American retailers, 69% reported experiencing AI-enabled fraud in the previous year, with only 3% saying they felt very prepared to handle increasing AI-enabled attacks. These figures cover AI-enabled fraud broadly, including deepfakes and AI-written phishing.
How to prevent fraud in 9 steps
- Use Shopify Payments
- Deploy IP fraud scoring tools
- Use verification software
- Limit order quantities
- Bolster your store policies
- Review risky orders
- Train employees on your fraud prevention plan
- Regularly update cybersecurity measures
- Keep accurate records
1. Use Shopify Payments
Shopify Payments provides built-in card testing protection and proxy detection. The fraud prevention tools flag suspicious activity. Shopify also declines near-certain fraud before the payment reaches the bank for authorization.
Shopify reports that its machine learning model blocks about 90% of card-testing attacks on guest credit card checkouts, intercepting suspicious payment attempts before they reach the payment network. This also helps protect legitimate sales: repeated card-testing attempts can damage a merchant’s standing with banks and lead to more declined customer payments.
US store owners with a US Shopify Payments account also get Shopify Protect coverage for qualifying Shop Pay orders at no additional cost. The coverage applies to fraudulent and unrecognized chargebacks when the order meets the eligibility, fulfillment, and tracking requirements. For covered disputes, Shopify reimburses the disputed amount and the chargeback fee.
Eligible orders must be fulfilled with valid tracking within seven days of placement and marked in transit by the carrier within 10 days to qualify for protection.
2. Deploy IP fraud scoring tools
IP fraud scoring assesses the risk associated with an IP address, using signals such as proxy traffic or unusual transaction patterns.
When evaluating additional fraud tools, look for two related checks:
- Velocity checks. Flag bursts of activity, such as several payment attempts with different cards from the same IP address.
- Device fingerprinting. Uses browser and device characteristics to recognize returning devices and identify repeat attempts even when an IP address changes.
Shopify gives you fraud indicators on the Basic plan or higher. For stores on Grow or higher, or those using Shopify Payments, you also receive low-, medium-, and high-risk recommendations for eligible online credit card orders. These assess overall order risk using multiple signals, including payment checks and unusual device or network activity.
Medium- and high-risk orders are flagged on the Orders page and highlighted in order notification emails you subscribe to. Use the overall recommendation and suggested next step to guide your review.
3. Use verification software
Payment verification checks the card details and helps establish whether the cardholder authorized a purchase. Three common controls perform different checks:
- Address Verification System (AVS). Compares the numeric portion of the billing address and postal code with the card issuer’s records. Shopify displays available results in fraud analysis. An optional AVS filter declines charges that fail postal-code verification.
- Card Verification Value or Code (CVV/CVC). Checks the card’s three- or four-digit security code. Shopify displays available results and offers an optional filter for failed CVV checks. Saved-card transactions, such as Shop Pay purchases, skip fresh CVV verification.
- 3D Secure 2 (3DS2). Lets the card issuer assess transaction data and request authentication, such as a code or bank-app approval. Shopify Payments integrates 3D Secure checkout and triggers authentication when the issuing bank requires it. Qualifying authenticated payments shift liability for fraudulent chargebacks under card-network rules.
Review optional AVS and CVV decline filters under Settings > Payments > Shopify Payments > Manage. In the Fraud prevention section, select Reduce credit and debit card fraud. To adjust the filters manually, turn off Use automated settings.
4. Limit order quantities
Set quantity limits based on how much customers typically buy. Shopify’s native add-to-cart limit caps each product variant within a single order. For example, a limit of 10 allows 10 units of each size-and-color combination, rather than 10 items across the entire cart.
Adjust the limit under Settings > Checkout > Advanced preferences > Add-to-cart limit. Shopify displays a recommended limit based on your sales history, which you can adjust.
Exceptions include draft orders, Shopify POS carts, logged-in B2B buyers, and variants with untracked inventory or continued selling when out of stock. Quantity limits can reduce the number of units exposed in a single fraudulent order, but they don’t prevent someone from placing multiple orders.
5. Bolster your store policies
State when customers can return an item and what condition it must be in. For clothing, explain the rules on wear and attached tags for change-of-mind returns.
For example, Glossier’s refund policy states that returns must be processed within 30 days of receiving the order, requires an order number, and identifies gift cards and store-specific merchandise as final sale.

Check each returned item against the original order before approving a refund. If you run a loyalty program, explain how refunds affect earned points and enforce that rule when processing returns. Make these terms easy to find before purchase and in order confirmation emails.
In Shopify, configure return rules under Settings > Policies to set return windows, return shipping costs, and final-sale items. When self-serve returns are enabled, these rules determine which items customers can request to return.
6. Review risky orders
Review medium- and high-risk orders before fulfillment. Investigate these three warning signs:
- Mismatched details. Billing, shipping, or IP locations conflict. A gift purchase or travel can explain a legitimate difference.
- Unusual order sizes. A purchase is far larger than the customer’s usual order, or several small orders in quick succession could indicate card testing.
- Repeated declines. Multiple failed payments, especially with changing card details, can indicate attempts to test stolen cards.
With Shopify Flow, you can configure a workflow to capture payments for low-risk orders and tag medium- and high-risk orders for review. Choose the Order risk analyzed trigger so the workflow waits for the assessment. Set payment capture to manual when a workflow will control capture.
For example, SilkSilky flags high-risk orders with Shopify Flow and holds payment on those orders while staff contacts the customer to confirm partial card details.
7. Train employees on your fraud prevention plan
Teach employees how to handle the situations they encounter in their roles:
- Recognize suspicious payment attempts and phishing messages.
- Pause fulfillment when an order needs investigation.
- Check unusual refund requests against the original order.
- Report suspected fraud to a designated person.
Practice with a past fraudulent order and a legitimate order that was flagged. Explain what prompted the review and how the team reached its decision.
8. Regularly update cybersecurity measures
Protect staff accounts with unique passwords and two-step authentication. Install operating system and browser updates on devices that access your store.
In Shopify, you can require two-step authentication for individual users under Settings > Users. Select the user and set the Secure sign-in method to required, then click Save. If you’re on a Shopify Plus plan, you can require a secure sign-in method for all users across your organization.
Give employees only the permissions their jobs need, and deactivate unused accounts. Review login history and user activity for unfamiliar sessions or unexpected changes to users and roles.
9. Keep accurate records
Keep delivery confirmation and customer correspondence with each order. In the 2026 Global eCommerce Payments and Fraud Report, 83% of surveyed merchants reported using compelling evidence to fight first-party misuse.
For Shopify Payments disputes, Shopify adds available order information to the response and submits it on the due date. Add evidence held elsewhere, such as customer emails, before that deadline. If you submit the response early, further edits are locked.
For fraudulent or unrecognized chargebacks on Shopify Protect orders, Shopify handles the dispute and reimburses the disputed amount and chargeback fee. Other claims, such as goods not received, follow the standard dispute process and fall outside that coverage.
How to prevent chargeback fraud
A customer can receive an order, keep it, and then falsely claim the purchase was unauthorized.
In a 2026 survey of fraud and payments professionals, respondents named payment fraud as their costliest fraud risk.
These steps can help reduce avoidable disputes and prepare your store to challenge fraudulent claims.
Use a recognizable billing descriptor
Set your billing descriptor, the name on a customer’s card statement, to the store name shoppers recognize.
In Shopify Payments, edit your customer billing statement under Settings > Payments > Shopify Payments > Manage. Include a current contact number so customers can ask about a charge. Add the statement name to order confirmation emails.
Retain representment evidence
Representment is the process of challenging a chargeback with evidence. Save order confirmations, tracking records, and customer messages with each order. Match your response to the claim: a delivery confirmation addresses a claim that an item never arrived, but doesn’t by itself prove the cardholder authorized the purchase.
Shopify Payments collects available order data. Add relevant correspondence before the response deadline. Assign each dispute to a staff member and record the deadline as soon as you receive the notification.
Understand how 3D Secure applies to your store
Check when your payment provider requests 3D Secure authentication and how it records the result. Shopify Payments has an integrated 3DS checkout flow that triggers when the card issuer requires it.
Successfully authenticated payments can shift liability for fraudulent chargebacks to the issuer, subject to card-network rules. Disputes about delivery or product quality follow the usual chargeback process. Shopify Protect covers eligible Shop Pay orders for qualifying US stores.
Monitor chargeback and fraud metrics
Track your chargeback rate, fraud losses, and dispute reasons each month. Record the disputed amount and chargeback fee separately so you can see the amount at stake in each case.
Investigate changes by cause. For example, a rise in unrecognized charges warrants a descriptor check, but repeated non-delivery claims warrant a review of tracking and fulfillment records. After tightening a rule, check whether it is also rejecting legitimate customers.
Top fraud detection and prevention tools
Payment provider controls check transactions within your payment service. Stand-alone screening platforms assess orders through a separate app or integration. Chargeback guarantees reimburse qualifying chargebacks, subject to the provider’s coverage terms.
Shopify’s built-in tools cover payment-provider controls and chargeback coverage, plus order screening, monitoring, and workflow automation:
| Shopify feature | Category | What does it do? |
|---|---|---|
| Fraud analysis | Built-in order screening | Shows fraud indicators on Basic plans and higher. Low, medium, or high risk recommendations for eligible online credit card orders are available with Shopify Payments or on Grow plans and higher. |
| Shopify Protect | Chargeback coverage | Reimburses the disputed amount and chargeback fee for covered fraudulent or unrecognized chargebacks on protected orders. |
| Dynamic 3D Secure | Payment-provider control | Requests 3D Secure authentication through Shopify Payments when required by the card issuer. |
| Card testing protection | Payment-provider control | Provides integrated protection against card-testing attempts at Shopify Payments checkout. |
| Dispute management | Payment-provider dispute handling | Collects available order evidence and submits chargeback responses for Shopify Payments disputes. Merchants can add relevant records before submission. |
| Proxy detection | Payment-provider control | Flags customers using proxy services or proxy IP addresses on stores using Shopify Payments. |
| Shopify Flow | Workflow automation | Runs configured actions after risk analysis, such as notifying staff or canceling high-risk orders. |
Fraud analysis and Shopify Protect cover different gaps. Fraud analysis flags risky orders, but it doesn’t reimburse you if a chargeback follows. Shopify Protect reimburses fraudulent and unrecognized chargebacks on eligible Shop Pay orders, but disputes about product quality or non-delivery follow the standard chargeback process.
Shopify Protect
Shopify Protect covers eligible Shop Pay orders for US businesses with a US Shopify Payments account. For every Shopify Payments store, Shopify Protect also includes the fraud and dispute tools in the table above, such as card testing protection and dispute management. When a protected order receives a covered chargeback, Shopify reimburses the disputed amount and chargeback fee and handles the dispute.
Check the order’s Shopify Protect status before fulfillment. Eligible orders contain only physical items requiring shipping. Fulfill the order and add valid tracking from a supported carrier within seven days of purchase.
The shipment must be in transit within 10 days of purchase. Changing the shipping address after checkout voids coverage. See the full Shopify Protect eligibility requirements.
Wyllo
Wyllo is a stand-alone fraud-screening platform available through a Shopify app. NoFraud became Wyllo in March 2026 after acquiring Yofi. The platform screens payments and examines returns, refunds, and customer service interactions for signs of abuse. Payment screening uses AI, with optional expert review on paid plans.
Its optional chargeback guarantee covers qualifying fraud disputes on orders that receive a Pass decision. Under its published policy, reimbursement comes as credits toward future Wyllo services. You must supply the required evidence and submit reimbursement claims at least seven business days before the chargeback response deadline.
Fraud prevention FAQ
What are the most common types of fraud?
In the 2026 Global eCommerce Payments and Fraud Report, the three most commonly reported fraud types were refund and policy abuse (41%), real-time payment fraud (38%), and phishing, pharming, and whaling (37%).
These figures reflect the share of surveyed fraud professionals whose businesses experienced each attack in the previous 12 months. They reflect exposure to these external fraud risks, not their share of total fraud losses.
How do you know if someone is scamming your business?
Signs that someone is scamming your business include repeated payment declines, conflicting customer details, and requests to change shipping details after checkout. These signals warrant a risk assessment but don’t prove fraud. Pause fulfillment while you review the order’s fraud analysis and payment history.
Using several signals together can help detect fraudulent transactions and manage fraud risk. Contact the customer to verify the purchase and any requested changes before shipping.
What is an example of fraud prevention control?
One example of a fraud prevention control is the Address Verification System (AVS), which checks the numeric parts of a customer’s billing address and postal code against the card issuer’s records. In Shopify Payments, merchants can activate a filter that declines payments that fail AVS postal-code verification when the issuing bank supports that check.
Ecommerce fraud prevention efforts combine payment checks with internal controls, such as requiring manager approval for unusual refunds.
How can you recover money from an ecommerce scammer?
To recover money you sent to an ecommerce scammer, contact the financial institutions or payment providers involved immediately to request a reversal or transfer recall. Recovery isn’t guaranteed.
To challenge a fraudulent chargeback, submit relevant order records and evidence addressing the specific claim before the response deadline. Check whether Shopify Protect or another chargeback guarantee covers the loss.
How do you report an ecommerce scammer?
Report an ecommerce scammer to your payment provider and any marketplace involved. In the US, file reports with the FTC and the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center. Include payment dates and amounts, the scammer’s contact details, and a description of what happened, and keep copies of receipts and messages. For complex cases, certified fraud examiners can help investigate suspected fraud and examine the supporting records.












